Best Fishing Charters in Maui — Top 2 Ranked (2026)
Ranked by aggregated TripAdvisor + Google reviews · Updated April 2026
Strike Zone Maui is our top pick for fishing charters in Maui — rated 4/5 across TripAdvisor and Google. Finest Kind Sportfishing is a solid runner-up, starting at $250.
Book Strike Zone Maui — From $174 →Rankings
| # | Operator | Score | Price | Best For | Book |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Strike Zone Maui Top Pick | 4/5 | $174+ | Best Overall | → Book |
| 2 | Finest Kind Sportfishing | 3.8/5 | $250+ | Runner-Up | → Book |
Strike Zone Maui
Best OverallFishing Charters · Maui · $174–$600 · 4/5 composite
100+ years combined crew experience. Shared bottom fish + combo trips. Maalaea Harbor.
“Well. The crew was a SOLID 5 STARS. Organized. On time. Helpful. Friendly. Alot of people on the boat, but I felt we were all well Managed. The cleaning of the catch, and dividing up the trolling catch was a plus. The 3 star rating comes …” — TripAdvisor · ★★★☆☆
“Save your money. It’s not the boat or crew or captain, they were top notch. It’s the quality of fishing on Maui, those are days long gone. I was the only one to catch a fish. A whopping 5 inches!! Fish California waters. Cheaper and better …” — TripAdvisor · ★☆☆☆☆
Finest Kind Sportfishing
Runner-UpFishing Charters · Maui · $250–$1900 · 3.8/5 composite
Operating since 1972. 3 boats. Relocated to Maalaea post-Lahaina fire.
“Fantastic day on the water with 5 Mahi Mahi boated. Painless to schedule as Adam was very helpful. Captain Joel and Jake are great guys and absolute pros on the water. Highly recommend!” — Google · ★★★★★
“Wow! The best sport fishing charter I’ve ever had! The reservation process was super easy and informative. Captain Fuzzy put us on the fish and deck hand Ekolu effortlessly put the fish on the boat. Its nice to see these men genuinely enjoy…” — Google · ★★★★★
How We Ranked These
Rankings are based on composite scores aggregated from TripAdvisor and Google reviews, weighted equally (50/50). Operators within 0.1 points are considered tied and ranked by starting price. Operators without published review data are listed last. We update scores monthly from live API data.