Hawaii Scout

Strike Zone Maui vs Finest Kind Sportfishing

Fishing · Maui · Updated 2026

TLDR Verdict

Strike Zone Maui wins with a higher composite score (4/5 vs 3.8/5), based on aggregated TripAdvisor and Google reviews.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Strike Zone Maui Winner Finest Kind Sportfishing
Composite Score 4/5 3.8/5
TripAdvisor 4.1★★★★☆
Google 3.9★★★★☆ (84 reviews) 3.8★★★★☆ (103 reviews)
Starting Price $174 $250
Price Range $174–$600 $250–$1900
Islands Maui Maui
Book → Book Strike Zone Maui → Book Finest Kind Sportfishing

What Reviewers Say

Strike Zone Maui

TripAdvisor ★★★☆☆

Well. The crew was a SOLID 5 STARS. Organized. On time. Helpful. Friendly. Alot of people on the boat, but I felt we were all well Managed. The cleaning of the catch, and dividing…

TripAdvisor ★☆☆☆☆

Save your money. It’s not the boat or crew or captain, they were top notch. It’s the quality of fishing on Maui, those are days long gone. I was the only one to catch a fish. A who…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

This is our 2nd time going on Strike Zone (1st time in 2015). The first trip was phenomenal- we caught so many fish & the crew caught 2 Ono. We gave away some of our fish because w…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Captain Dana, Jordan and Carl were knowledgeable and kind with a group of “pond” fishers. It was not a bountiful day for any of the crews out that day, yet we had two catches wort…

Finest Kind Sportfishing

Google ★★★★★

Fantastic day on the water with 5 Mahi Mahi boated. Painless to schedule as Adam was very helpful. Captain Joel and Jake are great guys and absolute pros on the water. Highly re…

Google ★★★★★

Wow! The best sport fishing charter I’ve ever had! The reservation process was super easy and informative. Captain Fuzzy put us on the fish and deck hand Ekolu effortlessly put the…

Google ★★★★★

Booked my trip with Adam last minute. Hes knowledgeable and got us in with 2 days notice on an 8hr trip. Captain Joel had us ontop of fish ALL DAY long. Jake was great on the dec…

Google ★★★★★

These guys are the best, great communication leading up to date and we crushed it with 8 mahi-mahi the day of.

Choose Finest Kind Sportfishing If...

  • Starting price of $250 fits your budget
  • You're visiting Maui
Book Finest Kind Sportfishing →

Strike Zone Maui

Top Pick

From $174 · Maui

4/5 composite

Read Full Review Book Strike Zone Maui →

Finest Kind Sportfishing

From $250 · Maui

3.8/5 composite

Read Full Review Book Finest Kind Sportfishing →