Hawaii Scout

Four Winds Maui vs Trilogy Excursions

Snorkeling · Maui · Updated 2026

TLDR Verdict

Trilogy Excursions wins with a higher composite score (4.9/5 vs 4.8/5), based on aggregated TripAdvisor and Google reviews.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Four Winds Maui Trilogy Excursions Winner
Composite Score 4.8/5 4.9/5
TripAdvisor 4.8★★★★★ 4.8★★★★★
Google 4.8★★★★★ (1,020 reviews) 5★★★★★ (7,824 reviews)
Starting Price $80 $160
Price Range $80–$180 $160–$250
Islands Maui Maui, Lanai
Book → Book Four Winds Maui → Book Trilogy Excursions

What Reviewers Say

Four Winds Maui

TripAdvisor ★★★★☆

Was okay, I don’t think I’d do it again for how expensive it was. The weather/waves were bad so we only drove past the crater and did not snorkel (I know that isn’t their fault) …

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Great staff and captain. Took us to the molokini crater and provided an amazing lunch also!

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Went on this tour with my teenage daughter and it was great. Super clean boat, really good food, fun and professional environment. The Crew is knowledgeable and it's all easy to ma…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Incredibly friendly and helpful staff. Didn’t matter if it was your first time snorkeling or well experienced, they made it a worthwhile and memorable experience for everyone, A n…

Trilogy Excursions

TripAdvisor ★★☆☆☆

It was windy enough that they should have cancelled or offered to reschedule us. We bought the sunset whale watching trip since many years ago we loved seeing whales in the area, b…

TripAdvisor ★★★★☆

I was here the week of and just after Kona 2 storm. I booked the the tour to Lanai trip. Weather necessitated a late departure and slightly earlier return and skipping the snorkel…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

We were on the Lana’i trip yesterday Tues. after the weekend storm. Captain Mark did an amazing job of driving the boat to keep us dry & while the weather wasn’t ideal we still saw…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Wow! This company has it down. I have been on so many boat tours throughout Hawaii and the Caribbean and have never had such an organized and care-free experience. From getting ont…

Choose Trilogy Excursions If...

  • You want the higher-rated option (4.9/5 vs 4.8/5)
  • Starting price of $160 fits your budget
  • You're visiting Maui or Lanai
Book Trilogy Excursions →

Four Winds Maui

From $80 · Maui

4.8/5 composite

Read Full Review Book Four Winds Maui →

Trilogy Excursions

Top Pick

From $160 · Maui, Lanai

4.9/5 composite

Read Full Review Book Trilogy Excursions →

More Snorkeling Comparisons