Hawaii Scout

Magic Sportfishing vs Boom Boom Sportfishing

Fishing · Oahu · Updated 2026

TLDR Verdict

Magic Sportfishing wins with a higher composite score (4.6/5 vs 4/5), based on aggregated TripAdvisor and Google reviews.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Magic Sportfishing Winner Boom Boom Sportfishing
Composite Score 4.6/5 4/5
TripAdvisor 4.7★★★★★ 3.9★★★★☆
Google 4.4★★★★☆ (63 reviews) 4.1★★★★☆ (134 reviews)
Starting Price $250 $250
Price Range $250–$1775 $250–$2100
Islands Oahu Oahu
Book → Book Magic Sportfishing → Book Boom Boom Sportfishing

What Reviewers Say

Magic Sportfishing

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Best day with the best captain and crew we fought a tuna and over 30 fish. I wish everyone could experience this!!!!!!!

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

My first time on a deep sea fishing charter. The crew were awesome! supportive and informative, walking me through how to land the best fish of the day a 56 inch mahi mahi! We cau…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Amazing experience! Never had before. We would like to have something like this in Brazil. Amazing crew. Certainly would do it again. Very profissional!!!!!!!

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Eine unglaubliche Erfahrung mit einem unfassbar netten und kompetenten Team - der Kapitän fand die besten Stellen und eine Menge Fische, die wir mit (einiger) Hilfe und positiven A…

Boom Boom Sportfishing

TripAdvisor ★☆☆☆☆

Don't book this company! Unreliable! Unprofessional! No show! No call! They take your money and leave you hi and dry. They did a great job of ruining my guests anticipation of a g…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Amazing experience. Searched internet and made calls for over a month to make the right choice. Tony always replied with honest, but upbeat answers. It's difficult to make a choice…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

I just wanna say thanks to boom boom Sport fishing for the excellent trip that we had. I wanted to thank Captain Joseph and mate Liam for most awesome experience with my son grand …

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Just went fishing today for my birthday - and had such an incredible time! Thank you so much to our captain Kaika and Mikey for helping make the day so special! (also shout out to …

Choose Boom Boom Sportfishing If...

  • Starting price of $250 fits your budget
  • You're visiting Oahu
Book Boom Boom Sportfishing →

Magic Sportfishing

Top Pick

From $250 · Oahu

4.6/5 composite

Read Full Review Book Magic Sportfishing →

Boom Boom Sportfishing

From $250 · Oahu

4/5 composite

Read Full Review Book Boom Boom Sportfishing →