Magic Sportfishing vs Boom Boom Sportfishing
Fishing · Oahu · Updated 2026
Magic Sportfishing wins with a higher composite score (4.6/5 vs 4/5), based on aggregated TripAdvisor and Google reviews.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Magic Sportfishing Winner | Boom Boom Sportfishing | |
|---|---|---|
| Composite Score | 4.6/5 | 4/5 |
| TripAdvisor | 4.7★★★★★ | 3.9★★★★☆ |
| 4.4★★★★☆ (63 reviews) | 4.1★★★★☆ (134 reviews) | |
| Starting Price | $250 | $250 |
| Price Range | $250–$1775 | $250–$2100 |
| Islands | Oahu | Oahu |
| Book | → Book Magic Sportfishing | → Book Boom Boom Sportfishing |
What Reviewers Say
Magic Sportfishing
Best day with the best captain and crew we fought a tuna and over 30 fish. I wish everyone could experience this!!!!!!!
My first time on a deep sea fishing charter. The crew were awesome! supportive and informative, walking me through how to land the best fish of the day a 56 inch mahi mahi! We cau…
Amazing experience! Never had before. We would like to have something like this in Brazil. Amazing crew. Certainly would do it again. Very profissional!!!!!!!
Eine unglaubliche Erfahrung mit einem unfassbar netten und kompetenten Team - der Kapitän fand die besten Stellen und eine Menge Fische, die wir mit (einiger) Hilfe und positiven A…
Boom Boom Sportfishing
Don't book this company! Unreliable! Unprofessional! No show! No call! They take your money and leave you hi and dry. They did a great job of ruining my guests anticipation of a g…
Amazing experience. Searched internet and made calls for over a month to make the right choice. Tony always replied with honest, but upbeat answers. It's difficult to make a choice…
I just wanna say thanks to boom boom Sport fishing for the excellent trip that we had. I wanted to thank Captain Joseph and mate Liam for most awesome experience with my son grand …
Just went fishing today for my birthday - and had such an incredible time! Thank you so much to our captain Kaika and Mikey for helping make the day so special! (also shout out to …
Choose Magic Sportfishing If...
- ✓You want the higher-rated option (4.6/5 vs 4/5)
- ✓Starting price of $250 fits your budget
- ✓You're visiting Oahu
Choose Boom Boom Sportfishing If...
- ✓Starting price of $250 fits your budget
- ✓You're visiting Oahu
Magic Sportfishing
Top PickFrom $250 · Oahu
4.6/5 composite
Read Full Review Book Magic Sportfishing →Boom Boom Sportfishing
From $250 · Oahu
4/5 composite
Read Full Review Book Boom Boom Sportfishing →