Hawaii Scout

Humdinger Sportfishing vs High Noon Sportfishing

Fishing · Big Island · Updated 2026

TLDR Verdict

Humdinger Sportfishing wins with a higher composite score (4.7/5 vs 4.6/5), based on aggregated TripAdvisor and Google reviews.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Humdinger Sportfishing Winner High Noon Sportfishing
Composite Score 4.7/5 4.6/5
TripAdvisor 4.8★★★★★ 4.5★★★★★
Google 4.6★★★★★ (57 reviews) 4.6★★★★★ (70 reviews)
Starting Price $699 $500
Price Range $699–$1485 $500–$1500
Islands Big Island Big Island
Book → Book Humdinger Sportfishing → Book High Noon Sportfishing

What Reviewers Say

Humdinger Sportfishing

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

We had a wonderful day fishing with Humbdinger on December 16. Everything went very well. The captain and mate worked very hard and were very nice. My wife, son and I landed two bl…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

An outstanding deep-sea fishing charter! The crew was incredibly attentive, respectful, and genuinely focused on our success. We reeled in an impressive number of fish, thanks to t…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Capt Brett has decades of local fishing knowledge and will do his best to get you on the fish, top notch gear & great crew, can’t really ask for more. Will be back whenever I’m in …

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Captain Brett and mate Noah did a great job for us. My grandson, Alex, caught his first Ono (wahoo) and yellowfin tuna. We have enough fish for our entire trip now. I have been on …

High Noon Sportfishing

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Trip was awesome, exciting and informative. Sawyer was an amazingly hard worker the whole 6 hours we were out he didn’t stop working. While we were trolling Sawyer explained the re…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

Captain Dee and First Mate Sawyer are top notch guys and great fishermen. My wife and I had such a great time. We saw Pilot Whales, Hundreds of Dolphins and flying fish. All of t…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

We chose High Noon because we wanted a private boat that was family friendly. We had our 9, 13, and 16 kids with us. Captain D and Sawyer were exceptional. Sawyer taught everyone h…

TripAdvisor ★★★★★

We arrived early to find Captain Kevin and Jason already preparing Kuuipo for our days adventures! We spent some time catching the bait we required and began fishing just as the su…

Choose High Noon Sportfishing If...

  • Starting price of $500 fits your budget
  • You're visiting Big Island
Book High Noon Sportfishing →

Humdinger Sportfishing

Top Pick

From $699 · Big Island

4.7/5 composite

Read Full Review Book Humdinger Sportfishing →

High Noon Sportfishing

From $500 · Big Island

4.6/5 composite

Read Full Review Book High Noon Sportfishing →